The number of Chinese students admitted to US universities last year surpassed 170,000; a double-digit growth that has been the trend in recent years. After returning home, these students are likley to have a profound impact on China in the years to come.
Taiwan opened its doors to Chinese university students two years ago, and so far, about 1,000 Chinese students have seized the opportunity to study on the island. This number is not large compared to those studying in the States, but the process of adjustment is not as jarring since these students are staying in a country that shares a common language and cultural heritage. Yet, their stay might also be somewhat strange since politically, Taiwan still considers China as neither a friend nor an enemy. Given these similarities and contradictions, what then are these Chinese students’ impressions of Taiwan and how might they affect future cross-strait relations?
Allowing Chinese students into Taiwan is a highly political issue
President Ma Ying-jeou has promoted increased exchanges with mainland China since taking office in 2008. In the last four years, there were over six million cross-strait visits by the people of Taiwan and mainland China, with more than three million Chinese tourists visiting the island, plus 10,000 students on short-term and long-term exchanges. The first batch of 928 Chinese students came in September 2010, and another 724 came last September. Some of them left after one semester, while others will stay for four years, and even continue on to graduate studies in Taiwan.
In August 2010, Taiwan’s Legislative Yuan passed three bills relating to the entry of students from 41 selected Chinese universities to study at college campuses in Taiwan. The bills also set restrictions, with quotas that no more than two percent of the total freshmen population in Taiwanese colleges can be from China in any given school year, they are not permitted to work during their studies or to seek employment in Taiwan afterwards, and they are barred from applying for government positions in Taiwan.
There is a current over-supply of colleges in Taiwan given the island’s low birth rate and many schools have welcomed this opportunity to expand. However, due to the imposed restrictions, Chinese students have not even come close to the 2,000 yearly quota. This month, President Ma ordered a review of these restrictions to see if they may be amended in order to spur more cross-strait exchange of young students.
In May, the Central News Agency reported Chao Chien-min, the former vice chairman of the Mainland Affairs Council and a professor at National Chengchi University, held a discussion with Chinese students studying in Taiwan. In response to requests by these students that Taiwan’s government should relax the restrictions, Chao said that this is not a scholastic issue, but one which is highly political. Whenever there is a bill in relation to the exchange of people from the mainland, the Legislative Yuan becomes a battlefield between the ruling and opposition parties.
Bittersweet romance across the Taiwan Strait
A Chinese official in charge of Taiwan affairs also talked with the Chinese students studying in Taiwan during his visit last month, urging them to make use of this opportunity to make friends and even to date Taiwanese students. However, any romance is likely to be challenging given that Chinese students would need to leave immediately upon completing their allotted term or when they receive their degree.
The United Daily News reported on the story of Roger, a Taiwanese student who fell in love with a female exchange student from China. To maintain their relationship after his girlfriend’s return, he applied to a Chinese university for a one-semester exchange. Now back in Taiwan, Roger is in contact with his girlfriend through video phone. He hopes to continue the relationship by working in China for a Taiwan-funded enterprise after completing his 10-month military service in Taiwan.
In another romance, Deng Dong, a graduate student in Taiwan, was a part of a school group visiting China last year. While attending Beijing Union University, he met his girlfriend. It was love at first sight. Since becoming a couple, he has traveled to the mainland, while she has visited Taiwan as a tourist. However, there are barriers to their relationship. In the short term, his girlfriend complains about the expensive and difficult procedure in applying for an individual tourist visa to Taiwan. He plans to work in China, but worries that his future wife might not be able to find a job which matches her education as a foreign spouse in Taiwan.
The Central News Agency reported that Chen Po-yu, a mainland Chinese student studying at the University of Hong Kong, becomes anxious around 10 pm daily, which is the time she usually talks to her boyfriend in Taiwan via Skype. Chen met her boyfriend when she was a short-term exchange student in Taiwan two years ago. After dating for two months, she returned to Hong Kong. Since then, she met up with her boyfriend in China, Thailand, and Hong Kong. Her boyfriend even took a two-day flight to meet her parents in China.
Chen said she thought of pursuing graduate studies in Taiwan to be close to her boyfriend, but being from Gansu Province (western China), which is not included in the designated schools or areas from which individual Chinese can plan personal tours to Taiwan, Chen cannot visit Taiwan to study or visit relatives.
At the same time, Chen feels insecure due to the political uncertainty between the two sides. The couple has even discussed the possibility of a war breaking out between Taiwan and China in the future. Chen said, “The future is unpredictable, but I do not want the sad story of Niu Lang and Zhi Nu love story to happen to us.”
The love story is well-known in China. Niu Lang was a poor orphan cowherd, and Zhi Nu was the daughter of the God of Heaven. The fairy came down secretly to earth, fell in love with Niu Lang and married him. The God of Heaven soon found out and had Zhi Nu brought back to heaven.
Niu Lang followed Zhi Nu to heaven. He was about to reach his wife when the Queen appeared. She pulled off her hairpin and drew a line between the two. The line became the Silver River in heaven, otherwise known as the Milky Way.
Zhi Nu went back to heaven, spending her time weaving clouds. But she was so sad, and missed her husband across the Silver River so much that the clouds she weaved seemed sad. Finally, the Queen showed a little mercy, allowing the couple to meet once a year on the 7th day of the 7th lunar month on the Silver River. Their meeting date has been called Chi Xi, the Chinese Valentine’s Day.
From misinformation to mutual understanding
The Want Daily reported that due to the disparity of land and population across the strait, it is easy for the people from Taiwan to visit the mainland but Chinese citizens face a lot of restrictions in return. Even though cross-strait relations have improved in recent years, only Chinese spouses of Taiwan citizens can receive permanent residency in Taiwan. Though Chinese students can stay longer, they must return to the mainland after they complete their studies.
The Central News Agency reported that Chinese students place Taiwanese into two categories – those who have been to China and those who have not. The latter are mostly ignorant about the situation in China. During his stay in Taiwan, a Chinese student was repeatedly asked, “Are you not free on the mainland? Is it dangerous there? Is it easily being under arrest and sent to prison?”
This student believed that many Taiwanese are not fully aware of the situation in China because they get incomplete information from the news media. Some students expressed the hope that Taiwanese people will have a comprehensive understanding of China.
On the other hand, this Chinese student confessed that he thought Taiwan was a part of China before his visit to Taiwan. But after his stay in Taiwan, he has mixed feelings seeing the Republic of China’s flags flying everywhere, dispelling his earlier teachings.
Xia Xiao-you, a Chinese student from Xiamen, Fuzhou province, wrote an article entitled “Taiwan syndrome” in her blog after returning to China. In it she described how she missed “Japanese cuisine, desserts, and the hot milk she could easily buy at convenience stores in Taiwan. They also offer services such as calling for a taxi, booking train tickets, paying cell phone bills, and the restrooms are generally clean there.” She added, “I miss the free WiFi in Taipei. When I visit scenic locations and search for WiFi, up pops ‘I love Taiwan’ on the front page. It happened at Sun Moon Lake, Taichung Railway Station and Green Island Harbor. Every time I saw this WiFi logo, the feeling would be echoed in my heart – I love Taiwan.”
The United Daily News reported that a Chinese student from Beijing with the surname Lu said, one day he lost NT$3,000 (US$100.00) at the Taipei Main Station, and thought that the money was gone forever. To his surprise, he found the money at the station’s customer service desk. On another occasion, he was touched when a child walked him 0.6 miles to set him on the right direction in central Taiwan. However, the most incredible thing for him was to hear Taiwanese people criticize their president so blatantly.
Let them know the meaning of diversity and tolerance
Li Kai-wei, professor at Chung Hua University, wrote in a letter to the editor of the United Daily News that the Chinese government has been actively encouraging Taiwanese students to enroll at Chinese universities while the Taiwan government is still hesitant. It is estimated that there are 7,000 Taiwanese students in China while there are only 1,000 Chinese students in Taiwan. He said it is predictable that Taiwan will suffer a brain drain in the future because Taiwanese students rarely return after graduating in China, yet Chinese students are forbidden to seek employment in Taiwan after graduation.
The Want Daily stressed, “Taiwan is a diversified society, and we should treat the Chinese students as part of this diverse society. We should use this opportunity to show them what is diversity and what is tolerance. The Chinese students are the ‘pioneers’ who have a deep understanding of Taiwanese society. They are young and as innocent as a white sheet of paper, and can develop in many ways. They will bring to China what they have learned in Taiwan and might even become Taiwan’s supporters.”
The United Daily News has collected and edited pictures of Chinese students in Taiwan. Please visit the link http://vimeo.com/39931650 for details. (Unfortunately, the captions are only in Chinese).